Chapter 3 : Academic Storm

=

The royal schoolroom smelled of old parchment, beeswax, and the faint mustiness that permeated all ancient palace rooms. Sunlight streamed through leaded glass windows, illuminating dust motes dancing in the air. Arthur took his usual seat at the back of the room, Richard standing guard by the door.

It was the weekly history lesson, taught by Master Alistair Thorne—a scholar of middling ability but considerable ambition. In Arthur''s previous life, Thorne had been one of Lily''s earliest pawns, using his position to subtly undermine Arthur while praising Edward and Lily''s "natural cleverness."

Today, Arthur could see the trap being set.

Thorne entered with an air of self-importance, his black robes swishing. He carried a stack of books that Arthur recognized—advanced texts on Albion''s constitutional history, far beyond what a twelve-year-old prince should be expected to know.

"Good morning, Your Highnesses," Thorne said, his gaze lingering on Arthur just a moment too long. "Today we shall examine the complexities of royal succession laws. A challenging topic, but one befitting future rulers."

Arthur kept his expression neutral. He knew what was coming. In his first life, this lesson had been a humiliation—Thorne had asked increasingly obscure questions until Arthur was reduced to stammering silence, while Lily and Edward exchanged smug looks.

Not this time.

Thorne began with a lecture on the Great Charter of 1215, deliberately using convoluted language and referencing documents Arthur shouldn''t have read. Arthur listened patiently, noting each exaggeration, each minor factual error Thorne inserted to test whether anyone was paying close enough attention to catch them.

After twenty minutes, Thorne turned to Arthur. "Prince Arthur, perhaps you could enlighten us on Article Seven of the Charter? The one concerning the rights of barons to refuse extraordinary taxation?"

It was a trick question. There was no Article Seven in the original charter—that provision had been added in the 1297 reissue. A twelve-year-old wouldn''t know the difference.

Arthur met Thorne''s gaze. "Master Thorne, I believe you''re referring to the 1297 Confirmation of the Charters, not the original 1215 document. The original had no numbered articles—that was a later innovation by chroniclers. The provision about baronial consent for taxation appears in what later scholars labeled Clause Twelve of the 1215 charter, but it''s phrased quite differently from the 1297 version."

A stunned silence filled the room.

Thorne blinked. "I... that is..."

"Would you like me to quote the relevant passages?" Arthur asked pleasantly. "In the 1215 version, it reads: ''No scutage nor aid shall be imposed on our kingdom, unless by common counsel of our kingdom...'' Whereas the 1297 version simplifies it to: ''No tallage or aid shall be laid or levied by us or our heirs in our realm, without the good will and assent of the archbishops, bishops, earls, barons, knights, burgesses, and other freemen of our realm.''"

Edward, who had been doodling in the margin of his notebook, looked up in confusion. Lily''s expression had gone from anticipatory gleam to tight-lipped anger.

Thorne recovered with effort. "A... astute observation, Your Highness. But perhaps we should focus on the practical implications rather than textual minutiae."

"Of course," Arthur said. "The practical implication being that the 1297 version expanded the consent requirement from just barons to include knights and burgesses—a significant shift toward broader representation. A shift that, incidentally, laid the groundwork for the Parliament we have today."

He could see Thorne scrambling. The tutor had expected to expose Arthur''s ignorance, not have his own knowledge challenged.

"Let us move to a different topic," Thorne said, flipping through his books with slightly trembling hands. "The royal prerogative. Prince Arthur, can you explain the concept of nullum tempus occurrit regi?"

Another trap. The Latin phrase—"time does not run against the king"—was legal doctrine, not something taught to children. But Arthur remembered studying it in his previous life, remembered the long hours in the library after everyone else had gone to bed, trying to compensate for the education he wasn''t receiving at court.

"It means the crown is not bound by statutes of limitation," Arthur said. "A king can bring legal action at any time, regardless of how long has passed. However," he added, "this was significantly limited by the Crown Suits Act of 1540, which established a sixty-year limit for most actions. The doctrine now applies mainly to matters of state rather than private property disputes."

Thorne''s face had gone pale. "Where... where did you learn this?"

"The palace library has an excellent collection of legal texts," Arthur said. It was true enough—he had spent time there in both lives. "I find constitutional history fascinating. The balance between royal power and subjects'' rights is, after all, the foundation of our kingdom."

He was playing a dangerous game. Showing too much knowledge would raise questions. But showing too little would leave him vulnerable. He had to walk the line carefully.

For the next hour, Thorne tried again and again to trip Arthur up. He asked about the War of the Roses succession disputes, about the legal intricacies of Henry VII''s claim to the throne, about the differences between English common law and the Roman law still used in parts of Europe.

Each time, Arthur answered correctly—but always with just enough hesitation to make it plausible that he was simply a very studious boy. He referenced books he could reasonably have read, cited scholars whose works were in the palace library, and occasionally "admitted" he wasn''t sure about some minor detail.

The effect was devastating. By the end of the lesson, Thorne was sweating, Edward was looking at Arthur with something like respect, and Lily was seething.

As the lesson concluded, Arthur delivered his final blow.

"Master Thorne," he said as the tutor was gathering his papers, "I noticed you referenced Bishop Burnet''s History of the Reformation when discussing Henry VIII''s break with Rome. An excellent source, but you might want to consult Professor Whitgift''s more recent analysis. Burnet made several errors in his dating of key events that Whitgift corrected using the Vatican archives."

Thorne froze. "Errors?"

"Yes," Arthur said. "For instance, Burnet dates Cardinal Wolsey''s fall as October 1529, but the papal correspondence shows it was actually late September. A small difference, but accuracy matters in scholarship, don''t you think?"

It was a deliberate humiliation. Arthur was not only showing he knew more than the tutor—he was publicly correcting him on his own specialty.

Thorne''s face flushed crimson. "I... I shall review the sources. Thank you for the... correction, Your Highness."

As Arthur left the schoolroom with Richard, he could feel Lily''s eyes burning into his back.

---

The news reached the king that afternoon.

Arthur was in his chambers, reviewing a map of the kingdom''s northern borders, when a page arrived with a summons. "His Majesty requests your presence in the solar, Your Highness."

Richard, who had been sharpening his sword by the window, looked up. "Shall I accompany you?"

Arthur considered. "Yes. But wait outside. If this is about the lesson, I need to handle it alone first."

The king''s solar was a spacious room with a view of the river. Henry VIII stood by the window, his bulk silhouetted against the afternoon light. He turned as Arthur entered.

"Arthur." The king''s voice was neutral. "Master Thorne came to see me. He was... agitated."

Arthur bowed. "Father. I hope I haven''t caused trouble."

The king studied him. In his previous life, Arthur had always found these encounters intimidating. Henry was a large man, physically imposing, with a reputation for sudden rages. But now, Arthur saw something else—the weariness around the eyes, the slight tremor in the hands that hinted at too much wine, the petulance of a man used to being flattered.

"Thorne says you embarrassed him," the king said. "Corrected him in front of your siblings. Is this true?"

Arthur chose his words carefully. "I asked questions, Father. And when Master Thorne made factual errors, I... pointed them out. Gently, I thought. Is it wrong to seek accuracy in our studies?"

The king''s expression shifted. "Thorne said you knew things no boy your age should know. Legal doctrines. Historical details. Where did you learn this?"

"The library, Father," Arthur said. It was the same answer he''d given Thorne, but he delivered it with just the right mix of earnestness and deference. "When I''m not at lessons or training, I read. The librarians have been very helpful."

"You read legal texts for pleasure?" The king sounded skeptical.

"I read about our kingdom''s history and laws," Arthur said. "I want to understand how Albion works. How you rule. Is that... wrong?"

It was a clever pivot—framing his studies as admiration for his father''s rule rather than personal ambition.

The king was silent for a long moment. Then he grunted—that same noncommittal sound Arthur remembered from the hunt. "Thorne wants you removed from his class. Says you''re disruptive."

Arthur''s heart sank. If he was removed from lessons, he''d lose access to the schoolroom, to the structured time with his siblings, to the opportunities to demonstrate his abilities.

"Father," he said, keeping his voice steady, "if my questions are disruptive, I''ll refrain from asking them. But I want to learn. I want to be... worthy of our family name."

Another calculated appeal. The king valued family pride above almost everything.

Henry studied him again, his gaze sharp. "Thorne also said Lily was there. That she seemed... displeased."

Arthur didn''t deny it. "Lady Lily prefers lessons to be less challenging, I think. She finds detailed discussions tedious."

It was a subtle dig—implying Lily was lazy or unintellectual without directly saying so.

The king made a dismissive gesture. "Lily has other qualities. But you..." He trailed off, then said, "You''ll continue with Thorne. But be respectful. A prince should know his place."

"Yes, Father."

As Arthur bowed and turned to leave, the king added, "And Arthur?"

"Father?"

"Don''t make an enemy of Thorne. He has friends at court. And he tutors your brother Edward."

The warning was clear. But so was the implication—the king was taking notice. He was paying attention.

"Thank you for the advice, Father," Arthur said.

When he emerged from the solar, Richard was waiting in the corridor. "Well?"

"The king noticed," Arthur said quietly as they walked back to his chambers. "That''s what matters."

"But Thorne will be an enemy now," Richard said.

"Yes," Arthur agreed. "But some enemies are worth making. Thorne was already Lily''s creature. Now he''s openly mine. That''s cleaner, in a way."

Back in his chambers, Arthur went to the window. The palace spread out below him—a maze of courtyards and corridors, of alliances and enmities, of secrets and schemes.

He had won today''s battle. He had humiliated Thorne, impressed (or at least intrigued) the king, and further frustrated Lily. But wars weren''t won with single victories.

Richard stood beside him, following his gaze. "What now?"

"Now we prepare," Arthur said. "Thorne will seek revenge. Lily will try something else. And the king''s attention..." He shook his head. "The king''s attention is fickle. Today he''s interested. Tomorrow he might forget I exist again."

"But you made him remember," Richard said.

"For now," Arthur said. He turned from the window. "We need to be ready for what comes next. Lily won''t accept defeat. She''ll escalate."

"And Thorne?"

Arthur smiled, but there was no warmth in it. "Thorne is a small man with a large ego. He''ll make a mistake. And when he does, we''ll be ready."

The afternoon sun cast long shadows across the room. Somewhere in the palace, Lily was plotting. Thorne was nursing his wounded pride. Edward was probably trying to comfort Lily without understanding why she was angry.

And Arthur was here, with Richard at his side, planning his next move.

The academic storm had passed. But the political one was just beginning.

---